Ding Dong, the Witch is Dead

Carla Naragon started a discussion on a professional blog for Marriage, Family Therapists.  This essay was her first post on a new blog.  I found it to be thought-provoking.  

It’s a longer “read” than you might be used to but take the time.  The issue is much larger than just one man, Bin Ladin.  

 Here’s her post and several of the replies.  

http://carlanaragon.com/blog/

“Osama Bin Ladin is dead. It’s on TV, it’s on the radio. It’s in the air and in the water. There is no escaping it. The question is, how should I feel about it?

“Should I celebrate by singing the classic song from the Wizard of Oz:“Ding Dong! The Witch is dead. Which old Witch? The Wicked Witch! Ding Dong! The Wicked Witch is dead.

Or should I meditate on the profound wisdom of Martin Luther King, Jr: ”I mourn the loss of thousands of precious lives, but I will not rejoice in the death of one, not even an enemy. Returning hate for hate multiplies hate, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars. Darkness cannot drive out darkness: only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate: only love can do that.”

Perhaps the correct answer is both. There is a part of the human experience that craves revenge and feels hungry for violence. To deny that we are all capable of feeling violent would be a mistake. It would be like denying that water is wet. Ignoring the truth doesn’t make it less true.”

It’s also true that love begets love and violence begets violence. Just like 1+1=2. An eye for an eye, would have us all blind. Punishment is not the answer.

If the human race is to survive and thrive, we need to acknowledge our pain. Feelings and behavior are 2 separate things. We can learn to acknowledge our primal reaction to threat AND behave from a more evolved place. Acts of love and compassion are most needed exactly when it is most difficult. This is as true for the individual as it is for couples, families and communities. What is our planet if not one gigantic human habitat?

We currently live in a culture of “us” and “them”. The news reflects our own internal struggle between the compassionate, warm, loving and generous people we strive to be and the greedy, fearful and aggressive parts of us we struggle to keep in the shadows.

The bottom line: It’s okay to feel anger, hate and rage. It’s not okay to act it out. The human race, along with our planet will thrive if we chose to act from a place of love and compassion. Remember, love begets love and violence begets violence. 1+1=2. If we want a different outcome, we must choose a different action.” by Carla Naragon

A response to Carla:
“His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama emphasized the need to find a distinction between the action and the actor. He said in the case of Bin Laden, his action was of course destructive and the September 11 events killed thousands of people. So his action must be brought to justice, His Holiness said. But with the actor we must have compassion and a sense of concern, he added. His Holiness said therefore the counter measure, no matter what form it takes, has to be compassionate action. His Holiness referred to the basis of the practice of forgiveness saying that it, however, did not mean that one should forget what has been done”

Another response to Carla:

“I think its great that we got a bad guy, the one responsible for the murder of 3,000 innocent Americans on 9/11 and I am feeling a little scared that we may stir up anti-American sentiment among the citizens in the middle east. I would feel a little more celebratory if we reformed the American health care system which send more than 18,000 uninsured people to their deaths annually (that’s 5 times the amount of people killed in 9/11, but in only 1 year).”

What’s your opinion?


3 thoughts on “Ding Dong, the Witch is Dead

    • Hi Becca, You totally got it! That’s the whole point. There’s a good chance that you have more than one opinion. It’s even possible that your opinions have opinions. With so many opinions, there is a sound statistical chance that some of your opinions may be in conflict with one another.

      I find that watching the news stirs up inner conflict. My inner warrior and my inner humanitarian are struggling to find common ground. It’s not easy. While I value both aspects of myself, right now I think it’s a good idea the let the humanitarian be in charge (at least until things settle down a bit). Don’t get me wrong, the warrior is of great value, but when inflamed tends to make poor decisions.

      Good luck on your search for clarity! Let me know if you find it 🙂

      Like

  1. I appreciate all of your thoughtful responses. Many thanks to Judy for generously posting this discussion on CREATIVITY TO THE MAX.

    I too am afraid of what is being stirred up, within and without of America. There is a difference between the action of removing a dangerous threat and creating propaganda to “chum the waters”. For those of you who aren’t into shark fishing, “chumming the water” is when you pour blood and dead fish into the ocean so as to attract hungry sharks to your boat.

    “His Holiness referred to the basis of the practice of forgiveness saying that it, however, did not mean that one should forget what has been done”. This quote from Richard gives us simple a profound guidance. The personal advantage to practicing forgiveness is that it allows you and me to let go of hate. Hate is bad for our hearts, bodies, families, friends and communities.

    Not forgetting, keeps us safe. We can treat a threat as a threat. We do not need hateful propaganda to keep us safe. Love begets love and violence begets violence. We share one planet. The division of our countries and cultures is an allusion. We are all one species who share one planet. We can choose to actively heal one another or instigate more destruction. Each path will have its own natural and logical consequences.

    Right, wrong, justification and other such words will be irrelevant when all we are left with is death and ruin. One planet and one another. That’s all we have. Action and consequence

    Like

Wadda ya say? Comments HERE! (Depending on energy, I may not be able to respond to every comment but I READ every word of every comment!)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.